An individual user may print out a pdf of a single chapter of a monograph in oso for personal use. The term is one of a group of english words formed from the various derivatives of the greek verb semaino to mean or to signify. Together, they wrote the book the meaning of meaning in 1923. In three studies, this research examined the relations among referential thinking, selfprocessing, and paranoia. The babelist theory of meaning an inaugural lecture. Referential definition of referential by the free dictionary. Meaning and psychology knowing the meaning of a word, sentence is being in a psychological state. On the millianreferential theory, there is only one kind of meaning, viz. Generative grammarian theory, meaning, nonreferential theory, referential. Reviews 8 theories of meaning and classifies them into 4 categories. You must understand the relationship about this theory in every language there are words like tree and run and red which seem to have an obvious relation to objects and events and descriptions of things in the world around us. Expressions stand for thingsobjects in reality words function like labels, sentences mirror stateof affairs o n designate. However, the theory also applies to other parts of speech as well.
Meaning and reference the traditional conception of meaning combines two assumptions. Criticisms of this position are often associated with ludwig wittgenstein in the 19th century, mathematician and philosopher gottlob frege argued. Referential definition and meaning collins english. The referential theory of naming consists mainly of two separate doctrines, one concerned with the mechanism of reference, the other with the contribution of reference. The meaning of a word is grasped in relation to its surroundings 1 theories of meaning. The referential theory of meaning lecture 3 theory of. The meaning of any linguistic expression e is es referent the thing it refers to. The meaning of cockapoo is a concept a set of ideas.
Selfreference occurs in literature and film when an author refers to his or her own work in the context of the work itself. His interest in language and meaning was awakened by charles kay ogden 1889 1957. An introduction to philosophy of language, department of philosophy, university of aberdeen coordinator gerry. It has been given by two famous linguists ogden and richards. Mentalist theory of meaning in semantic is very important concept. A use theory of meaning a use theory of meaning chapter.
A brief look at ogden and richards theory of meaning. Theories of meaning stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Referential, related to the word reference, is a term that varies somewhat in meaning depending on the context of use. May 02, 2010 there are other theories of meaning that surpass the referential theory, though they have their own problems. Each theory s contribution to the current debate on what is meaning is. Referential theory of meaning use theory of meaning.
We must distinguish the meaning of cockapoo and the meaning of cockapoo. The object denoted by a word is called its referent. In referential theory, meaning is defined as label which is in human consciousness to point out the out side world. I also deal with the problem of coreferring terms and make refinements to avoid the paradoxes.
In philosophy, it also refers to the ability of a subject to speak of or refer to itself, that is, to have the kind of thought expressed by the first person. Bertrand russell and gottlob frege have both been associated. Nov 03, 20 the referential theory the idea is that linguistic expressions have the meanings they do because they stand for things. Referential theory of meaning is that the meaning of a term is the things in the world it refers to. Even frege, who thought that meanings senses were public entities not private ideas, allowed that the grasping of a meaning is an individual. Practical, in practical theory, says something about use and value of the theory. Pdf theories of meaning and different perspectives on. This paper is an essay for course of introduction to philosophy of language level 2. Chapter 6 is a critique of a recent translationbased theory of meaning due to stephen schiffer. Referential theory is confounded by terms that have the same referent but different meaning, such as morning star and evening star. According to the referential theory, the meaning of an expression is. Each theorys contribution to the current debate on what is meaning is.
The sense or significance of a word, sentence or symbol. For the theory of ideology has commonly sought to examine the ways in which meaning or ideas affect the conceptions or activities of the individuals and groups which. Chapter 5 is a critique of the conventionbased theories of meaning of david lewis and brian loar. The meaning of a word determines the things it refers to. Pdf using talk to scaffold referential questions for. Semiotics the aaa framework aristotle, augustine, and aquinas. Selfreference occurs in natural or formal languages when a sentence, idea or formula refers to itself. There are other theories of meaning that surpass the referential theory, though they have their own problems. Referential definition is of, containing, or constituting a reference. Theory of reference, freges puzzle, sense and reference lecture 3 if we want to have a theory. Basically though it refers to two or more objects, thoughts, sensory perception, emotional states, ideas, etc. Referential thinking is the tendency to view innocuous stimuli as having a specific meaning for the self and is associated with personality traits and disorders. The above graph depicts a session of psychoanalysis. According to the referential view of meaning, the meaning of this proper name is a specific person in the world.
One common sense theory is that expressions have meanings because they stand for things. A study of ideational metafunction in joseph conrads. Yet, their ubiquity notwithstanding, it is quite unclear what sociologists mean by the words theory, theoretical, and theorize. Areas where the green line which depicts referential activity using the weighted referential activity dictionary is at a peak, and the blue line which shows the speakers use of reflection words, e. A direct reference theory also called referentialism or referential realism is a theory of language that claims that the meaning of a word or expression lies in. One word can mean different things in different languages. Horwich applies this theory to provide an account of semantic stipulation. In fact, richard montague 1960 set out to construct a very sophisticated, highly technical theory in which even words like those. The referential theory the idea is that linguistic expressions have the meanings they do because they stand for things. Gabriel abend northwestern university theory is one of the most important words in the lexicon of contemporary sociology. Frege distinguished between a words semantic extension and its semantic intension.
The standard view is that the referent of a predicate is a property. Semantics semantics historical and contemporary theories of meaning. The noun semantics and the adjective semantic are derived from semantikos significant. In the philosophy of language, the descriptivist theory of proper names also descriptivist theory of reference is the view that the meaning or semantic content of a proper name is identical to the descriptions associated with it by speakers, while their referents are determined to be the objects that satisfy these descriptions. Criticisms of this position are often associated with ludwig wittgenstein. Semantics, also called semiotics, semology, or semasiology, the philosophical and scientific study of meaning in natural and artificial languages.
The naive referential theory of meaning the meaning of a word is exhausted by the object to which it refers. But before we discuss them, we will have more to say about how reference works. The referential theory of meaning referential theory of meaning. Ajdukiewicz, tarski, theory of meaning, simple names, syn. Referential definition and meaning collins english dictionary. The common feature of any referential approach is that meaning is in some form or other connected with the referent object of reality denoted by the word.
According to horwichs use theory of meaning, the meaning of a word w is engendered by the underived acceptance of certain sentences containing w. That aspect of meaning that can be expressed in terms of referents. I outline the basic features of the referential theory of meaning. Successful communication requires that the hearer correctly decode the speakers words into their associated ideas. The semantic extension of a word is the set of things the word denotes, while its semantic intension is the concept or meaning of the word. Richards was largely influenced by francis bacons idols of the market place. Ivor armstrong richards was born in england in 1893, and died in 1979. The task of this paper is to define the notion of referential semantics, to comment on its relevance to various epistemological issues and to prove a theorem that defines the class of logics whose logical constants are definable in terms of interpretations set forth by a referential semantics. In goldkuhl 2004 i have made an overview of different meanings of pragmatism. Bosco spring 2002 he who knows does not speak, he who speaks does not know. Iat811 metacreation 7 philippe pasquier, august 2006 referencial theories.
Reflection on linguistic schools theoretical description of meaning in translation 37 however, the referential or conceptual meaning of the same word may vary in different contexts. General, and seemingly natural, answer to questions of this form. In other words, we are free to accept the russellian theory of descriptions, supplemented with this claim that descriptions are very often used to direct listeners attention to the speakers referent, as kripke called what he took to be the referential analogue of gricean speakers meaning or, roughly, whatever the speaker. Pdf theories of meaning and different perspectives on information. Thereby one brings it about that w gets an underived. This is equivalent to asking what form a theory of meaning as opposed to a theory of reference should take. The referential theory of meaning referential theory. It introduces a perspective where the functional role and the purpose of. The meaning is formulated by establishing the interdependence between words and objects of reality they denote. Bacons belief that language functions as a potential barrier to understanding led richards to. Examples include cervantess don quixote, shakespeares a midsummer nights dream, the tempest and twelfth night, denis diderots jacques le fataliste et son maitre, italo calvinos if on a winters night a traveler, many stories by nikolai gogol, lost in the. Doc referential theory of meaning essay klara lackova.
In consonance with the referential theory, to be able to describe the meaning of the word table for example, there must be an object which. The notion of meaning is central to theories of language. However, there appears to be considerable disagreement regarding what a theory of meaning should do, and how it pertains to other linguistic issues wilensky, 1978. The use theory of meaning and semantic stipulation. Meaning is a relationship between two sorts of things. The inner, symbolic or true, interpretation, value, or message. The simple referential theory of meaning two claims. This theory is perhaps the most straightforward and the most intuitive when it comes to singular terms that is, terms that refer to specific objectspeople. Pdf the theory and practice of translation, by nida and.
And he appears to believe that the examples of the referential uses mentioned above are inexplicable on russells theory. The referential theory of meaning is one of the earliest theories that tried to explain what this concept means. Semantic stipulation proceeds by deciding to accept sentences containing an as yet meaningless word w. Even if reference cannot account for how we use language by itself, it is still an important part of how language works. Weve seen that a theory of reference assigns to each sentence a truthvalue and each.
View notes the referential theory of meaning lecture 3 from phil 08014 at university of edinburgh. Jul 25, 2017 the meaning of a word is grasped in relation to its surroundings 1 theories of meaning. The reference may be expressed either directlythrough some intermediate sentence or formulaor by means of some encoding. The referential theory of meaning referential theory of. Therefore, a translator should analyze the linguistic context of the original carefully, comprehend the specific conceptual. A theory of reference is a theory which pairs expressions with the contribution those expressions make to the determination of the truthvalues of. A direct reference theory also called referentialism or referential realism is a theory of language that claims that the meaning of a word or expression lies in what it points out in the world. Pdf even though automated information systems have been used in. Referential definition of referential by merriamwebster. As label, the meaning appears because of the process of observation and conclusion drawing through facts which make human possible to arrange and develop concept schemes. Theories of meaning 3 a similar argument for the incompleteness of the theory of reference the substitution of whole sentences.
The 17thcentury british empiricist john locke held that linguistic meaning is mental. A study of ideational metafunction in joseph conrads heart. The study of language and the theory of ideology as a social semiotic activity of language are two concerns which bear a close connection thompson, 1984. So construed, the meaning of an expression, according to locke.
1088 107 1511 206 339 1253 105 730 847 1296 865 1404 842 134 896 548 1348 1353 200 962 965 539 760 378 786 1243 844 1430 746 455 471